(I can't predict with 100% certainty that AI is going to get to a level where it will replace most people current skills, but I am basing off my prediction on the latest events. I am happy if you challenge my way of thinking about this issue.)
I agree, that would be the ideal way would be to opt out of certain categories if person submitting it is honest. But there are no processes that validate someone's honesty about these things with the advancements in AI.
Right now it's more of a thing where you include the category if you want to get feedback on your own work and not some AI tool's work.
I don't like it the way it is, I don't want people to use AI and claim it as their work, but what is anyone going to do about it? There is no way to validate that, except if they blatantly use Midjourney art - then you can use online tools to identify that they did use it.
All I mean is that there will be time in 1-2 years where submissions will be littered with AI music/sfx and art, and no one will be able to tell authentic work apart from AI generated.
I myself going to opt out of Audio and Graphics because I will definitely be using AI for those, but I bet 100% there is going to be at least someone who doesn't opt out and use AI. And some time in the future they will even win the competition in that category.
So the problem with these rules are they are outdated and won't work anymore. It's really sad that it's happening, but it is what it is, and we can't change that.
They kind of have always been hard to enforce, but other people could kinda see if the art was generated or if it was stolen from somewhere, not anymore.
I will very much miss the days when people from different fields gathered together and HAD to gather together(if they didn't have required skill) in order to get some kind of game working. Voice actors, musicians, sound designers, artists, programmers, designers.
Now it's going to be transformed into something different, dunno what. VIBE CODING, artistic vision, good music taste, sfx use-cases, etc. At least 3D art is safe for a little bit.
People are going to change field/type of work(because the skill is no longer going to be required this widely). And there won't be so many artists, voice actors and sound designers, probably even programmers. Thus with the lack of such people - most participants are going to use AI tools for that, especially because it's going to give them better results than entry level people that are usually interested in the JAMs.
Ludum Dare format has to change to adapt to it, or keep it's style and play cards in old school style. Because there is definitely going to be a more popular game JAM format where lots of students who like Video Games are going to participate and use AI.
This JAM might be one of the last LD jams where teams form out of people from different fields of work to create something with their "own" hands.
I would suggest everyone to enjoy it and remember it like it's the last time they are doing this kind of thing in teams. Future holds something different and it was lots of fun. People who were able to enjoy it for more years in the old format are lucky.
I know the post might sound sad, I am kinda sad about it, but I am also excited that the games are going to be more complex, bigger in scope, more fleshed out, and maybe we will find many new ways to collaborate.