edit -> Thanks for the positive comments. I didn't mean to sound so overly depressed by my scores. Also updated main post with the details from what I found from the the ensuing discussions.

At first I thought I did worse in ever category (% based on rating vs total compo submissions - higher is better)

Then I recalculated based on some feedback (% based on rating vs calculated compo submissions - higher is better)

Then I got the actual numbers I needed to get exact stuff (% based on rating vs total ratings by category - compo submissions - higher is better)

Can't say that I disagree with the ratings. 'Juice' plays way more into a well received game then the code that can't be seen. I spend some extra time putting on the polish that the game was missing a few days after the jam and I can even hardly tell that it is the same game.