IMPORTANT

i like this game 

Damn, the art is fantastic! Nice job overall, really cool entry.

This is amazing! I CANNOT believe you did a combination platformer/rhythm game, and that it plays so well! That must have taken a LOT of work. I am proud of you!

Loved the art, the humor (going left at the intro, van halen - jump :laughing:), the style. And the gameplay was really clean for a game jam game. I figured out the wall jump really quickly, and the mechanics of it were smooth and intuitive. Liked the level design with the 'false' floor bushes.

There seemed like there were some very trivial timing issues with some of the rhythm games. Overall, I think they were FANTASTIC, and added to the vibe of the game overall. Getting the upgrades felt really satisfying, and murdering people with my guitar was really fun.

I got the keyboard at the end, but then was unable to continue right? I'm assuming that's where the game finishes? Also, add an "exit" button to the main menu. :wink:

Again, great job. One of the most innovative and complex games I've seen so far this jam.

It looked promissing, sadly the game got stuck everytime when I defeated the first bass player :/

Wow! Grapics is really amazing! Gameplay is also great. Sadly, I've got error after defeating first enemy, but everything else looks very cool)

Had the same problem as @pilarius :(

Graphics, music, gameplay everything looks, sounds and feel amazing! The game is super long too, great job!

@pilarius @Mezeka @theufo Half of the people experiencing this issue and the other half is not. We are still investigating. If you can send us a Log file if it's okay( C:\Users\USERNAME\AppData\LocalLow\StiffNecks\The Treble Clef\Player.log ) to bora@brainoid.com

I'll try to fix it if I can find out what is going on. Thanks for giving it a try ^^

@rdcooper Thanks for the amazing feedback. Actually, that's only the 1/3 of the game. You missed an instrument behind. I actually show a message there but obviously it's a little off the screen. I guess from the keyboard player, if you go back down and right, there should be a collectible drum, then you are good to go :) Thanks for giving it a try and thanks for the amazing feedback.

nice art cool game i like it i wasnt
comfortable with A.S.D.F control at the beginning
but good game after all

Same problem here with the first enemy. I'm sending the logfile to you, seems an issue with the calculus of the success or something.

I love the idea and the assets, though. Let me know if you fix the game, I'd like to see more ;)

I beat the game!!! That was fun! The song after the boss was tough for me. I too got stuck unable to go right, fortunately I read the comments and found the drum below. I really like the graphics and the curvy land effects. I also really like brainoid's cat.

@theog @mezaka @theufo @pilarius Hey people! The issue is fixed. It was really stupid. If you have a nonUS display on your operating system, C# parses the number strings without considering the floating point value. And then my rhythm game puzzles get screwed. I added a line like

```
CultureInfo culture = new CultureInfo("en-US");
double number = Double.Parse("4.5", culture);
```

and it is fixed. I'd really appreciate if you could revisit our game and try to enjoy it. Much love!

So well polished
I had the idea of a mix of ryhtm game and action but ist hard with keyboard
Maybe attribute the sound with 1234 ?

No button feedback >:|

Pretty cool concept :D

Couldn't go past the first enemy but I'm amased by the beautiful word you did here! The concept is great, I really like the graphics and the light that focuses on the character. Loved to have an ingame tutorial and the popup with the pattern to learn was so neat. I'd play a further developed version of it! Great job!

@tommyflower Thank you. Just to clarify. You couldn't get past the first enemy because it was too hard?

I did it! i finished the piece haha

Well done, i like it, the ground textures and level design was a bit unclear to begin with, i was not sure if i was supposed to be able to walk over some spots, or if i was supposed to be balancing something, or whatever i was supposed to do, i had a hard time with it in the beginning.

I do like how you executed the rythm game though, it's solid, challenging and works well, felt a little out of sync on one of the tracks so i got a little de-synced haha. I found that you could just hit every button, as long as it was on timing, there should be a penalty for missing, and also a penalty for being hit by enemies

@kekkodude Thanks for the lovely feedback. I often tend to make the jam games fairly easy for players to be able to see the most of the content, that's why I didn't implement the penalty for missing thing, people are already having difficulties :) But you are right, in a full game, that's a must have feature!

For the level design I didn't really have too much time, I literally wrote 2 games at the same time :) Everything you say is correct. Thanks again. :)

@brainoid yes :D probably I missed something, because after that I kept falling down and had no clue where to go next.

@tommyflower Ok, just wanted to make sure, there's no bug and you just failed to get past it :) Thanks anyway for trying.

Really polished! It was hard to tell what was a death pit and what was a secret (though you need to go down there anyways) area. Part of it might be the camera focuses too high up so all drops feels scary.

@brainoid lol I'll play again then! :D

Damn. So great, in all aspects. cannot describe it.

@ivexnuke I agree. We didn't have much time to spend on the level design while literally making 2 games at the same time :) You are totally right. Thanks for playing! :D

Very solid entry. I really enjoyed the idea of ​​putting together the soundtrack as you collect the instruments. My only complaint would be the rhythm minigame. I think it should go horizontal rather than vertical, it would get easier and make more sense with the keys we need to press.

Thanks for the feedback, I hope you didn't have to rotate your monitor to play the minigame :P

Wow, great entry! Very innovative, fun and with a fantastic mood. Congrats for the team!

It's a very cool music game, tank you for fun )

This game looks so amazing!!! I wish I could play it, I'm on mac :cry:

@carloso We have some shader issues on Mac, I wish we didn't :( Sorry. Thanks for the input <3

Nice game, nice graphics, let's rock \m/


It would be cool if the mini-games were more clear when you hit the notes. In General, very high quality. It was fun to play. The graphics are nice.

Nice! I love how I can walk left and off the stage while getting a little message about giving up. lol The execution is good and the music fits well with the overall mood of the game. The art style is fun and I can't help but think a little bit about Scott Pilgrim but that isn't bad. I did struggle a little bit with the learning a new instrument section having to use "a s d f" being a little fast for me and my fingers not used to that. So, my recommendation is to perhaps allow the player to have the option to choose a different set of keys like "Arrow Keys" as it might be easier for them and make that part of the game more enjoyable. Very cool :D

Hey, just to let you know I’ve been making Ludum Dare 45 gameplay videos and I’ve put your game in my video! You can watch it here:
https://youtu.be/S9nZaGbYfVE

NO BUTTON FEEDBACK. <3

Despite that, thanks for submitting your game for me to play on my livestream!

If you’d like to rewatch the playthrough, you can find it here: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/494941349?t=3h13m37s