Paint It Black by SnoringFrog

[raw]
made by SnoringFrog for LD26 (COMPO)
Make the entire screen black by moving around it while the enemies attempt to undo your work. You can kill them, but if you try and miss you'll get a 5s penalty.

Arrows move. Space eats/attacks. Shift pauses. Ctrl slows player movement down (for getting those pesky single-pixel lines). S toggles music.

There's a bit of a slowdown issue due to the way the win-state is calculated. This can be mostly avoided if you leave some space uncolored near the top-left until near the end of the game.

Developed in XNA/C#
All art done in MS Paint
Music from automaker-c
"Eat" sound from bfxr
Font is "Pixel Square 10" from http://www.dafont.com/pixel-square.font

My first LD. I got lucky with the idea for this one. "Paint It Black" by The Rolling Stones came on Spotify shortly after the theme was released and that's where the idea came from.

Ratings

Coolness 89% 2
Overall 2.70 1027
Audio 2.58 630
Fun 2.37 1072
Graphics 2.29 1108
Humor 2.35 470
Innovation 2.91 728
Mood 2.47 952
Theme 3.46 632

Feedback

mtrc
29. Apr 2013 路 14:00 UTC
Non-XNA link is broken at the moment. :(
AleksandarDev
29. Apr 2013 路 14:04 UTC
Great idea, nice game... I didn't manage to play it through cause it starts to lag after a while (i guess you draw rectangle of textures on every move - this must be optimized)
馃帳 SnoringFrog
29. Apr 2013 路 22:44 UTC
mtrc, that link should be fixed now.

Aleksandar - That problem was actually a lot worse previously, though I know it still causes issues. It can be avoided if you leave something near the top-left corner open for most of the game, since the major culprit is the loop to check for the win-condition, which works from top-left to bottom right.
qdowngames
01. May 2013 路 04:20 UTC
Reeeally difficult. Can you actually win? I wont way it wasn't fun though!
馃帳 SnoringFrog
01. May 2013 路 04:40 UTC
Yes, you can actually win! My final times were usually within 3-7 minutes, depending on how overzealous/inaccurate I got with the space bar.
nseward
01. May 2013 路 05:06 UTC
I enjoyed it. I didn't read the part about the spacebar at first so I was thinking that this was impossible.
DaveDobson
01. May 2013 路 05:16 UTC
I got the lag thing that others mentioned, at about 5 minutes. It was fun before that - I don't know that there's any strategy other than killing all the white guys first and then sweeping out the black, which takes a while. I found that I didn't have great control over my guy, but it was fun to play. Definitely minimalist!
Otoris
01. May 2013 路 05:27 UTC
I liked it, until it lagged :( Really quite fun concept ^^
Dietrich Epp
01. May 2013 路 07:32 UTC
Can you make a version that doesn't have an installer? I already have the XNA runtimes required so an installer shouldn't be necessary...
馃帳 SnoringFrog
01. May 2013 路 08:04 UTC
Dietrich, the first link, the .ccgame, shouldn't require an installer, I believe. It'll unpack the files (kinda works like another zip file), but shouldn't need an install.

Let me know if I'm wrong about that though; I don't have another computer to test it on to check, and this is my first time trying to distribute a game from XNA.
Dark Acre Jack
01. May 2013 路 08:08 UTC
Listening to the inspiration track certainly enhances this experience.
Jesper Oskarsson
01. May 2013 路 08:28 UTC
After I killed off all the white cubes it didn't feel challenging any more, maybe some more could spawn during the whole game?

I like the concept tho, If it was a bit more challenging I would enjoy it for longer.

Good job!
Aceria
01. May 2013 路 08:46 UTC
Unable to play because I didn't have a dedicated graphics card in my laptop... I really need to upgrade! (No score given.)
meat_popsicle
01. May 2013 路 14:28 UTC
a setup file :(
馃帳 SnoringFrog
01. May 2013 路 17:28 UTC
Dietrich, meat_popsicle: I'm uploading another version that doesn't use an installer. Let me know if it works or not.
killerstarbunny
01. May 2013 路 21:45 UTC
Awesome really cool idea I had a problem running it there was the lag I used the setup file without XNA.
recursive frog
02. May 2013 路 07:06 UTC
Can't leave a rating on this one since I'm not on a windows machine.
馃帳 SnoringFrog
02. May 2013 路 17:44 UTC
Sorry about that, frog. As soon as final exams are done, I'm hoping to look into moving my game to Monogame and hopefully being able to export Linux/OSX versions. Unfortunately, that's still 4-5 days away, unless I can squeeze in the porting amid studying over the weekend.
Markavian
02. May 2013 路 20:53 UTC
So, killing the blobs is actually really important, and once I'd figured that out... it was fun, for a time, but then it got really dull again because then I had to paint over the entire map.
StMatn
02. May 2013 路 20:59 UTC
Nice mechanics. It was a bit of a pain to get the last pixels, becaus the game started to run extremely slow from one moment to the other. I had just 1/4 stripe left, so I dont think its about the drawing. It seemed so start bugging out, as the music stopped. Maybe restarting the audio-track caused the problems. However, I liked it. Good entry!
Blinked
03. May 2013 路 23:33 UTC
Very cool game :D
tankete
04. May 2013 路 05:21 UTC
Novel idea. Perhaps start with a smaller space and less enemies? My first time it took me > 7 minutes. Yes, I suck :)

Great job on your first Ludum Dare! (It was my 1st time too!)
burtlo
04. May 2013 路 05:38 UTC
After defeating the last scrubber it really feels like a lot of busy work to paint the entire screen black.
lightnarcissus
05. May 2013 路 03:12 UTC
Cool idea and I think you executed it fairly well.
Cybearg
05. May 2013 路 04:50 UTC
There's a neat idea here somewhere, but in practice, I didn't see it on display here.

I have to ask--is there any reason to NOT attack the enemies? Because I immediately started running over the enemies while spamming the spacebar to get rid of them all as soon as possible, which I did. But then I wonder--why require you to press spacebar? Why can't they just be killed by me touching them?

And then I'm left with a board of white which I then, line by line, have to paint black. This is very, very boring, at least to me. Same reason I didn't care much for Farming Simulator 2013 (though I know others did). It wouldn't be any better if there were still enemies--it would just be frustrating on top of tedious.

I'm sure something could be done with leaving trails and enemies/player affecting each other's trails, but just painting the screen doesn't work well at all, in my opinion.

Visuals were fine and music was good, though.
馃帳 SnoringFrog
05. May 2013 路 05:39 UTC
The reason you're required to press the space bar is because missing an enemy incurs a time penalty. Removing that aspect would ruin that part.

And yeah, it is fairly boring after you clear them out. That was something that I realized about halfway through development, but never did come up with a fix for. Part of me wanted to break this up into various levels and throw in some obstacles or new enemy types, and part of me thought implementing an online leaderboard would at least provide incentive to beat other people, but I didn't have time for either of those to be implemented, unfortunately.

So, I can't blame you for getting bored. My main goal here was to finish. This was my first Ludum Dare, my second game, and my first game made with graphics or with XNA; so I just told myself to get something done.

Thank you very much for taking the time to play it though, and thanks for the critique as well.

And actually, I just thought of another mechanic that might have made this game much more bearable. Oh well; too late.
Doublecaster
05. May 2013 路 12:03 UTC
Otherwise really good game except after playing a while it starts lagging alot.
free_napalm
10. May 2013 路 15:36 UTC
I think everything has been said. Nice at first, then it becomes a lawnmowing-like experience.
I hope "Sympathy for the Devil" will be your next LD title, could be a great game ;)
Puzzlem00n
13. May 2013 路 01:37 UTC
I agree with everything on the boringness/lawnmowing. Personally, I would have made it so that you only have to paint something like 80% black, and randomly spawned new enemies throughout the game. I also thought touching them and then pressing space was a rather boring way to kill them.

The graphics are oddly very good looking in their simplicity.
Hellequin
20. May 2013 路 15:42 UTC
Neat idea! Nice game, well done!
Monxcleyr Productions
21. May 2013 路 00:47 UTC
Combat was neat, and the chunks of black being erased looked neat, but after defeating enemies it was too tedious. Perhaps taking out combat and making winning be based on how much you can get black, or keep black.